We recently were contacted by Anspire who is a very talented digital artist and has recently delved into more traditional art.
She has been doing a comparison of various fine liner pens used in conjunction with alcohol markers and thought our readers might be interested in her findings.
Naturally, we were delighted to hear from her and she has some surprising results.
Table of Contents
Hello,
My name is Anspire and I make art and videos about all sorts of creative stuff. My latest obsession are alcohol markers and I am proud to announce I have collected all Spectrum Noir pens. I also own a few Copics and plan to expand my collection.
I am a primarily digital artist so when it came to traditional art, I was a complete beginner. It was not long until I finished my first few drawings and I realized my fineliner was feathering and smudging as I was coloring. Alcohol markers were obviously different from water-based ones and didn’t behave the same way.
A couple ruined drawings later, I decided it was enough and I went online and browsed Tiger Pens for options. I picked nine pens to review, all in black but in different sizes and waited for them to arrive so I could make my comparison video about with fineliner pens farewell with these types of markers.
Below is what came out of it, and if you are interested in the full version, you can find it linked at the end.
1. Fineliners tested with Copics
Pen brand | Size | Price* | Did it smudge? | Did it feather?** | Compatibility |
Pigma Micron | .05 | ££££ | Yes | No | None |
Kuretake ZIG Millenium | .005 | £££ | Yes | No | Low |
Edding 1880 | .02 | £££ | Yes | No | Low |
OHTO Graphic Liner | .01 | £££ | No | No | High |
Staedler Lumocolor permanent | S | £££ | Yes | Yes | None |
Staedler Lumocolor non-permanent | F | £££ | Yes | Yes | None |
Uni-pin Fine Line | 0.05 | £££ | Yes | No | Medium |
Berol Finewriter | N/A | ££ | No | No | High |
Stabilo point 88 | 0.4 | £ | No | No | High |
* ££££- more than £2; £££ – more than £1.50; ££ – between £1.50 – £1, £ – less then £1
** Feathering happens when the ink does not smudge but moves around on the paper, making lines thicker and blurry.
2. Fineliners tested with Spectrum Noir
Pen brand | Size | Price* | Did it smudge? | Did it feather?** | Compatibility |
Pigma Micron | .05 | ££££ | Yes | No | None |
Kuretake ZIG Millenium | .005 | £££ | Yes | No | Low |
Edding 1880 | .02 | £££ | Yes | No | Low |
OHTO Graphic Liner | .01 | £££ | No | No | High |
Staedler Lumocolor permanent | S | £££ | Yes | Yes | None |
Staedler Lumocolor non-permanent | F | £££ | Yes | Yes | None |
Uni-pin Fine Line | 0.05 | £££ | Yes | No | Medium |
Berol Finewriter | N/A | ££ | No | No | High |
Stabilo point 88 | 0.4 | £ | No | No | High |
* ££££- more than £2; £££ – more than £1.50; ££ – between £1.50 – £1, £ – less then £1
** Feathering happens when the ink does not smudge but moves around on the paper, making lines thicker and blurry.
3. Overall, three pens stood out, all of them on the cheaper side.
Pen brand | Size | Price* | Did it smudge? | Did it feather?** | Compatibility |
OHTO Graphic Liner | .01 | £££ | No | No | High |
Berol Finewriter | N/A | ££ | No | No | High |
Stabilo point 88 | 0.4 | £ | No | No | High |
Since Anspire wrote this post, unfortunately, the Berol fine writers have been discontinued by the manufacturers, however, the Ohto Graphic Liners & the Stabilo Point 88 are still widely available.
4. Recommended Pens
Ohto Graphic Liner Pens
Check Price and Reviews on Amazon
Stabilo Point 88 Fineliner Pens
Check Price and Reviews on Amazon
I must add all pens feel and look great but for the sake of this post which only looks at how well they fare with alcohol markers, the other six were incompatible.
If you are interested to hear more about each one and see how they did for yourself, please check out the video below:
Follow Anspire for more:
YouTube: https://bit.ly/2b7EHIr
Twitter: https://bit.ly/2b0nQGD
DeviantArt: https://bit.ly/2aInt24
Pinterest: https://bit.ly/2bcMlUh
Thank you for this thorough post! This is exactly what I was looking for.
Thank you so much for preforming this test. I too was looking at all the fine liners to use with Copics.
Thank you-
Very helpful